Home
Attorneys
Capabilities
News & Insights
About Us
Join Us
Opportunity & Inclusion
Contact Us
Blog Logo
Blog Logo

Tucker Arensberg

Contact information

Email Address
BOOKMARK SHARE
View All News & Insights
BACK TO Tucker’S PROFILE

No Right to Jury Trial in ERISA Withdrawal Liability Case Involving Veil-Piercing and Evade-or-Avoid Theories, District Court Holds

Brian A. Pepicelli, Esq., bpepicelli@tuckerlaw.com, (412) 594-3953
Neil J. Gregorio, Esq., ngregorio@tuckerlaw.com, (412) 594-3911

In Board of Trustees of the PAMCAH-UA Local 675 Pension Fund v. SMAC Hawaii, Inc., 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 192966 (D. Haw. Sept. 30, 2025), the pension fund sought to collect over $610,000 in ERISA withdrawal liability from affiliated individuals and entities of the withdrawn employer. In a prior summary judgment ruling, the court held that two issues needed to be resolved at a trial: (1) whether the individual owners could be held personally liable under a veil-piercing theory, and (2) whether a transaction that resulted in one of the affiliated companies exiting the controlled could be disregarded as an evade-or-avoid transaction. In this follow-up ruling, the dispute was whether the trial on these issues was to be a jury trial (as demanded by the individual owners and affiliated entities) or a bench trial (as argued by the pension fund).

The court sided with the pension fund and granted its motion to strike the jury demand. The court reasoned that because the pension fund’s veil-piercing and evade-or-avoid theories are methods for enforcing withdrawal liability, and because there is no right to a jury trial in a withdrawal liability action, the trial should proceed as a bench trial.  

Key Takeaway: Regardless of whether a withdrawal liability issue is being litigated in arbitration or federal court, it will not be decided by a jury. Either an arbitrator or a federal judge will be the finder of fact.

October 08, 2025

Contact Now

Get support from our trusted attorneys.

    Serving our clients successfully since 1900

    The same attributes that have anchored over a century of success are still our guiding principles today.

    Capabilities Find an Attorney

    Stay up-to-date on the latest News & Insights by subscribing to our alerts

    Enter your email address below and be notified when we post new information.